A New Chapter
Trolley Square
Continuing the Payne Anthony legacy with the same expert team, the same exceptional service, and a renewed commitment to the Salt Lake City community.
Location Details
Plan Your Visit
Schedule a Visit
Book Your Appointment at Trolley Square
Reserve a time with one of our specialists for a personalized consultation, custom design session, or repair drop-off.
What We Offer
Our Services
Our Trolley Square location offers the full range of Jonathan's services, including custom jewelry design, expert repairs, certified appraisals, and private engagement ring consultations. Browse our curated collection in a warm, welcoming showroom, or sit down with one of our specialists for a personalized experience tailored to your needs.
A New Chapter at Trolley Square
For years, this space was home to Payne Anthony Creative Jewelers, a name known for craftsmanship and trust in the Salt Lake City jewelry community. Today, that legacy continues as Jonathan's Jewelry, with familiar faces and a continued commitment to personal service.
This new chapter brings together two established jewelry businesses with a shared commitment to skilled craftsmanship, honest guidance, and a personal experience for every client who walks through our doors.
What Our Clients Say
Reviews
Hear from clients about their experience with our team.
Find Us
Our Location
Visit us in Trolley Square for expert jewelry help.
Getting Here
Visit us inside the historic Trolley Square shopping center at 329 Trolley Square, Salt Lake City, UT 84102. Our showroom is on the main level near the West Entrance.
Free covered parking is available nearby. If you need help finding us, call (801) 328-0944 and our team will be happy to guide you.
Need Help?
Questions?
Give us a call at (801) 328-0944 or email diamonds@jonathansjewelry.com. Walk-ins are welcome during business hours, or book an appointment for dedicated one-on-one time with a specialist.
Closer to Cottonwood Heights?
Visit our location on Highland Drive in Cottonwood Heights.