Highest Prices, Honest Process

Transparent evaluations, top offers in cash, trade‑in or in‑store credit.

GIA Certified

Graduate Gemologist

Highest Prices

Transparent evaluations, top offers

Two Locations

Cottonwood & Trolley Square

Sell Your Jewelry

With gold prices on the rise, your old jewelry box may be holding hundreds or thousands of dollars worth of treasure. Now is the best time to turn your old, broken, and unwanted jewelry into cash.

Depending on the current demand in the marketplace, we may buy your old gold, silver, and platinum jewelry, as well as gold and silver coins.

Many times it is possible to evaluate your jewelry while you watch and tell you the value of what you have. If we are unable to do that while you watch, we typically will not need longer than 48 hours to evaluate. If you decide to sell, we may offer you in‑store credit, trade‑in value toward something from our showcases, or write you a check on the spot.

We pay the absolute highest prices and have an unmatched reputation for honesty and integrity.

"They turned my grandmother's ring into something modern that still honors the original. I wear it every day and think of her."

SARAH W. |  COTTONWOOD HEIGHTS

Two Extraordinary Locations

Visit us at either location or schedule a private appointment with
one of our experts.

Jonathan's Jewelry

COTTONWOOD HEIGHTS

6910 S Highland Dr, Ste 5 Cottonwood 

Heights, UT 84121

(801) 943-0303

Tue–Fri: 10am–6pm | Sat: 10am–4pm

Jonathan's Jewelry

TROLLEY SQUARE

(Continuing the Payne Anthony Legacy)

329 Trolley Square Salt Lake City, UT 84102

(801) 328-0944

Tue–Sat: 11am–7pm