Jonathan's Jewelry has proudly served the Salt Lake City community since 1976. For nearly five decades, we've earned the trust of generations of families through exceptional craftsmanship, honest service, and meaningful relationships. 

In 2024, we welcomed our second home at Trolley Square, extending that same commitment while carrying forward the Payne Anthony legacy.

Today, both locations operate as one team with one shared purpose: helping you celebrate life's most meaningful moments with jewelry you'll treasure for years to come.

Jonathan's Jewelry first opened its doors in Cottonwood Heights in 1976 with a simple mission: to provide exceptional jewelry, expert craftsmanship, and genuine personal service.

What began as a neighborhood jeweler has grown into one of Salt Lake City's most trusted destinations for fine jewelry, custom design, jewelry repair, appraisals, and restoration.

Our in-house goldsmith, Elias, continues that tradition by handcrafting and restoring treasured pieces with the same care and attention that have defined Jonathan's Jewelry for generations.

No pressure. No pretense. Just people who care about getting it right.

When Jonathan’s Jewelry expanded to Trolley Square in 2024, we did so with deep respect for the Payne Anthony legacy. In 2026, we welcomed clients into our newly remodeled showroom as Jonathan’s Jewelry, bringing a fresh look and expanded collections to this familiar location.

Today, that showroom continues to offer the same personalized service, trusted expertise, and welcoming experience customers have long appreciated, now backed by the Jonathan's Jewelry team.

Whether you visit our Cottonwood Heights or Trolley Square showroom, you'll find the same commitment to craftsmanship, lasting relationships, and making every visit feel personal from the moment you walk through the door.