HOW IT WORKS
Our Custom Jewelry Process
Every custom piece begins with your vision and ends with a one-of-a-kind creation you'll treasure for a lifetime.
One-of-a-Kind Engagement Rings
Your love story is one of a kind. Your engagement ring should be too. From selecting the perfect center stone to refining every design detail, we'll create a ring that's uniquely yours.
- Expert guidance selecting the perfect GIA-certified center stone
- Complimentary custom CAD renderings before production
- Crafted in platinum or 14k & 18k white, yellow, or rose gold
- Typical completion in just 4–6 weeks
Wedding Bands as Unique as Your Bond
From timeless classics to modern designs, create wedding bands that reflect your style. Choose matching sets, mixed metals, hidden gemstones, personalized engravings, and more.
- His & hers matching sets available
- Personalized engraving options
- Comfort-fit designs for everyday wear
- Lifetime resizing included
Pendants, Earrings & Beyond
Whether you're celebrating a milestone, reimagining a cherished heirloom, or creating something entirely new, our designers will bring your vision to life with a one-of-a-kind piece made to be treasured for generations.
- Transform cherished heirloom jewelry into something new
- Birthstone, initial, and personalized designs
- Custom gifts for businesses, teams & special events
- Professional appraisal included with every custom piece
Choose Your Location
Select a location below to book your In-Store Custom Design Consultation.
"They turned my grandmother's ring into something modern that still honors the original. I wear it every day and think of her."
SARAH W. | COTTONWOOD HEIGHTS
Custom Inspiration Gallery
Visit Us
Two Extraordinary Locations
Experience the personal attention that has defined fine jewelry in Utah for over five decades.
Jonathan's Jewelry
COTTONWOOD HEIGHTS
6910 S Highland Dr, Ste 5 Cottonwood
Heights, UT 84121
Tue–Fri: 10am–6pm | Sat: 10am–4pm
Jonathan's Jewelry
TROLLEY SQUARE
(Continuing the Payne Anthony Legacy)
329 Trolley Square Salt Lake City, UT 84102
Tue–Sat: 11am–7pm
Common Questions
Custom Design FAQ
Everything you need to know before starting your custom jewelry journey with us.
Most custom pieces take 4–6 weeks from approved design to finished piece. Simple modifications may be completed in 2–3 weeks, while highly intricate designs or pieces requiring rare stones can take 8–10 weeks. We'll give you a clear timeline during your consultation. Rush service is available.
Every custom piece is unique, so pricing depends on the design complexity, materials, and stones chosen. In most instances, personalizing your engagement ring costs no more than buying an engagement ring in our showcase. We provide a detailed quote after your initial consultation — no surprises, no hidden fees.
Absolutely! We love working with family heirlooms and personal stones. Bring your gems to your consultation — our gemologist will evaluate them and discuss the best setting options to showcase their beauty.
Yes — heirloom redesigns are one of our specialties. We can repurpose metals and stones from your existing piece into a completely new design, preserving the sentimental value while giving it a fresh, modern look.
We encourage scheduling an appointment so we can dedicate time exclusively to you. Walk-ins are welcome at both our Cottonwood Heights and Trolley Square locations, but custom design consultations benefit from a reserved time slot with our design team.
Yes, once you approve the final design and quote, a 50% deposit is required to begin production. The remaining balance is due upon completion at pickup. We accept all major credit cards, cash, check, and flexible financing options.
That's completely okay — most of our clients start with just a feeling or a rough idea. Our team is skilled at guiding you through inspiration, styles, and options. Bring any Pinterest boards, photos, or reference images you like, and we'll take it from there.
