Expert Jewelry Appraisals
Protect What Matters with a Professional Jewelry Appraisal
Professional jewelry appraisals for insurance, estate planning, and peace of mind. With a GIA Graduate Gemologist on staff and more than 50 years of trusted experience, Jonathan's Jewelry provides accurate valuations you can rely on.
Comprehensive Appraisal Services
Professional valuations by our GIA Graduate Gemologist, trusted, thorough, and accepted by all major insurers.
Protect What Matters with a Current Appraisal
Professional jewelry appraisals for insurance, estate planning, and peace of mind.
Professional Jewelry Appraisals
Jonathan's Jewelry provides professional jewelry appraisals performed by experienced gemological professionals. Whether you're insuring a new purchase, updating an outdated appraisal, settling an estate, or simply wanting to know the current value of your jewelry, we're here to help.
The value of diamonds, gemstones, and precious metals changes over time. An appraisal completed several years ago may no longer reflect today's replacement value, potentially leaving your jewelry underinsured if it's ever lost, stolen, or damaged.
A current appraisal gives you confidence that your insurance coverage accurately reflects the value of your treasured pieces while providing the documentation needed for insurance claims, estate planning, charitable donations, or resale.
Whether it's an engagement ring you wear every day, a family heirloom passed down through generations, or a valuable jewelry collection, our team will provide a thorough, accurate appraisal you can trust.
Why Update Your Jewelry Appraisal?
• Ensure your insurance coverage reflects today's replacement value
• Protect yourself from being underinsured
• Required documentation for insurance claims and estate planning
• Accurate valuations by experienced gemological professionals
• Recommended every 3–5 years or after significant market changes
"They turned my grandmother's ring into something modern that still honors the original. I wear it every day and think of her."
SARAH W. | COTTONWOOD HEIGHTS
Two Extraordinary Locations
Visit us at either location or schedule a private appointment with
one of our experts.
Jonathan's Jewelry
COTTONWOOD HEIGHTS
6910 S Highland Dr, Ste 5 Cottonwood
Heights, UT 84121
Tue–Fri: 10am–6pm | Sat: 10am–4pm
Jonathan's Jewelry
TROLLEY SQUARE
(Continuing the Payne Anthony Legacy)
329 Trolley Square Salt Lake City, UT 84102
Tue–Sat: 11am–7pm
Choose Your Location
Select a location below to book your appointment online.
Appraisal FAQ
Appraisal fees depend on the complexity and number of pieces. Contact us for a quote. We’ll confirm pricing before we begin.
Please plan to leave your jewelry with us for appraisal. Most single-piece appraisals are completed within 3–5 business days, while estate collections with multiple pieces may take 5–7 business days. We’ll confirm the estimated completion time when you drop off your jewelry. Same-day service is available only during designated appraisal events that specifically offer it.
Bring your jewelry and any existing documentation, such as prior appraisals, receipts, GIA reports, or certificates of authenticity. Let us know whether the appraisal is for insurance, estate planning, or another purpose. Please plan to leave your jewelry with us unless you have booked a designated appraisal event that offers same-day service.
We recommend updating your appraisals every 3–5 years, or sooner if precious metal or gemstone markets have shifted significantly. An outdated appraisal can leave you under-insured.
An insurance appraisal documents the replacement value for insurance coverage purposes. An estate appraisal determines fair market value, typically for probate, estate planning, or equitable distribution among heirs.
Absolutely. We appraise jewelry regardless of where it was purchased. Our assessment is independent and unbiased.
Yes. Our GIA Graduate Gemologist has experience evaluating antique and vintage pieces, including Victorian, Art Deco, and mid-century jewelry. We consider era, craftsmanship, and historical significance in our valuations.
We recommend booking an appraisal consultation and checking availability with your preferred location. The consultation is for discussing your appraisal needs and leaving your jewelry with us; it is not a while-you-wait appraisal. Same-day service is available only during designated appraisal events that specifically offer it.